Do state test scores predict SAT scores?

Key takeaways
- In Connecticut's data, about 4 in 10 students at the low end of proficient in math missed the PSAT 8/9 math benchmark.
- A math result below the state standard is a dependable early warning, with years left to close the gap.
- In SAT states, the spring junior-year state test is an official SAT attempt, so take a practice test that fall.
- A top state label alone can't tell you whether your child is closer to a 650 or an 800 in math.
State test results track SAT results fairly closely, usually more so in math than in reading, and in nine states the high school state test is the SAT itself. The catch is the label on the report. In several SAT states, "proficient" is defined as College Board's minimum benchmark for college readiness, so a proficient result says your child is on track for college coursework and very little about whether their SAT score will be competitive at the colleges on their list.
In which states is the SAT the state test?
In nine states, eleventh graders take the SAT during the school day as the state's accountability test. College Board's 2025 state reports list Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Indiana, Michigan, New Hampshire, New Mexico, Rhode Island and West Virginia, and each state's education department describes the same arrangement on its current pages. Colorado, Delaware, Michigan and Rhode Island also give a PSAT test statewide in earlier grades.
| State | Statewide SAT Suite tests, per the state education department |
|---|---|
| Colorado | PSAT in grades 9 and 10, SAT in grade 11 |
| Connecticut | SAT in grade 11 |
| Delaware | PSAT 10 in grade 10, SAT in grade 11 |
| Indiana | SAT in grade 11 |
| Michigan | PSAT 8/9 in grades 8 and 9, PSAT 10 in grade 10, SAT in grade 11 |
| New Hampshire | SAT in grade 11 |
| New Mexico | SAT in grade 11 |
| Rhode Island | PSAT 10 in grade 10, SAT in grade 11 |
| West Virginia | SAT in grade 11 |
Sources: each state's education department, linked in the table. Checked October 2026.
These arrangements change. Illinois gave its juniors the SAT for years before switching to the ACT in spring 2025.
In these states, the state score is an SAT score. Connecticut's education department describes its School Day results as comparable to scores from independent SAT administrations, such as weekend test dates. PSAT results from earlier grades come with grade-level benchmarks that College Board sets as steps toward the SAT benchmarks, so a family in Michigan or Colorado can follow their child's progress on one scale from eighth or ninth grade onward, and our PSAT to SAT score converter shows the SAT range a PSAT score points to. We've written about how to read each part of a PSAT score report.
How closely do state test scores track the SAT?
In most states, the state test is a different exam: Smarter Balanced in many states, or a test the state built itself. There, the relationship has to be measured, and three studies have done so with large samples.
The largest comes from California. Michal Kurlaender and Kramer Cohen of UC Davis matched the grade 11 Smarter Balanced scores of students who took the test in 2014-15 to their SAT scores. Among the roughly 72,000 who applied to the University of California, Smarter Balanced math correlated with SAT Math at .83, and Smarter Balanced English with SAT reading at .68. The figures for Cal State applicants were nearly identical. These students took the SAT before its 2016 redesign, so the numbers describe an older version of the test.
The second is federal. Researchers at ETS, working for the National Assessment Governing Board, linked the 2009 grade 12 NAEP scores of more than 15,000 students to their SAT scores. The math correlation was .91. The reading correlation was .74, which the authors judged too weak to support a direct score-to-score conversion.
The third looked at younger students. Connecticut's education department compared grade 8 Smarter Balanced scores from spring 2015 with the same students' PSAT 8/9 scores that fall. The correlations were .796 in English and .778 in math, which the department called "moderate."
Correlations in this range mean the two tests sort students in broadly the same order. They describe a pattern across thousands of students and still leave room for two students with identical state scores to land far apart on the SAT. In two of the three studies, math tracked more closely than reading.
What does "proficient" mean compared with the SAT benchmarks?
College Board's college and career readiness benchmarks are 480 in Reading and Writing and 530 in Math. A student who meets a section benchmark has a 75% chance of earning at least a C in a related first-semester, credit-bearing college course. The benchmarks are a floor for college coursework.
In several SAT states, the state's definition of proficient is that same floor. Michigan's 2026 guide to its state test reports states that "the proficient cut score and the College Board benchmark score are the same." Connecticut's "Met" level starts at 480 and 530, cut scores it set in 2016 together with Delaware, Maine and New Hampshire. Those two cut scores add up to 1010. The average SAT score for the class of 2025 was 1029, so a student can be proficient in both subjects with a total below that average. We've written about what counts as a good SAT score for a given college list.
In states with their own tests, "proficient" varies from state to state. A February 2026 federal report placed each participating state's proficiency standard on the NAEP scale and found a 49-point gap on that scale between the most and least demanding grade 8 reading standards among the 45 states it tracked over time. Its authors write that because "standards vary across states, the results of the various state assessments cannot be used to directly compare students' progress." Even within one state, two tests can set different bars. In a Mathematica study of more than 800 college freshmen in Massachusetts, students scoring at the MCAS math proficiency cutoff had a 62% chance of a C average or better in college math, against 85% for students at the PARCC college-ready cutoff.
What can a state test score tell you about SAT readiness?
Connecticut's grade 8 study is the most useful guide here, because it reports how many students at each state result went on to meet College Board's benchmark a few months later. Connecticut splits each of its four Smarter Balanced levels into a lower and upper band; Level 3 is the state's minimum expected performance.
| Grade 8 Smarter Balanced result | Met PSAT 8/9 Reading and Writing benchmark (410) | Met PSAT 8/9 Math benchmark (450) |
|---|---|---|
| Level 1, lower band | 4.6% | 2.5% |
| Level 1, upper band | 14.4% | 6.9% |
| Level 2, lower band | 34.7% | 15.9% |
| Level 2, upper band | 59.5% | 35.5% |
| Level 3, lower band | 78.8% | 60.6% |
| Level 3, upper band | 93.4% | 80.0% |
| Level 4, lower band | 97.9% | 92.3% |
| Level 4, upper band | 99.5% | 98.4% |
Source: Connecticut State Department of Education, spring 2015 Smarter Balanced and fall 2015 PSAT 8/9 results. Checked October 31, 2026.
Three readings follow from the table, with the caveat that it describes one state, one cohort and a test taken in ninth grade.
A result below the state standard is a dependable early warning, especially in math. At most about a third of students below Level 3 in math met the PSAT 8/9 math benchmark. That is a skills gap with years left to close it.
A result at the low end of proficient is weaker news than the label suggests. About 6 in 10 students in the lower band of Level 3 in math met the math benchmark, which means about 4 in 10 did not.
A result at the top level says your child is very likely to clear the benchmark, and not much more. State tests sort results into a few broad levels. On Michigan's SAT-based state test, "Advanced" in math covers every score from 650 to 800. For a student aiming at selective colleges, the distance between the bottom and top of that band is the whole question. In an SAT state, the report answers it: Michigan's report also gives the section score itself, so check that number before reading anything into the label.
What should you do instead?
Use the state score as an early signal and a practice SAT as the measurement. A full-length, timed practice test, taken under test conditions, shows where your child's score falls today, which sections and skills cost them points, and whether they struggle with the harder questions or with time. Sharp's free full-length practice test breaks the result down by skill and question difficulty.
Timing depends on where you live. In an SAT state, your child's spring junior-year state test is an official SAT attempt, and a practice test in the fall of junior year leaves time to prepare for it. The exception is a test taken with a state-allowed accommodation rather than one College Board approved, which produces a score that can't be sent to colleges; ask the school which kind your child has. Elsewhere, a practice test in tenth grade or the fall of eleventh grade sets a baseline before any official attempt. We've written about how to get the most out of each practice test.
A practice SAT shows how far your child's score is from their target, and Sharp can build a study plan from that score to test day.
Kim's take
Families in SAT states often treat the spring school-day SAT as one more state test, and some students walk in without ever having seen a full practice test. I tell them it's a free official attempt that colleges will see if they send it, so it deserves the same prep as a weekend date. Even one timed practice test a few weeks before helps.

Kim Strauch, SAT Tutor & Founder
Kim scored a perfect 1600 on the SAT, graduated summa cum laude from Dartmouth, and founded Sharp after years of tutoring students one-on-one.
How we write and fact-check our postsFrequently asked questions
Is an SAT School Day score the same as a weekend SAT score?
It is an official SAT score on the same 400 to 1600 scale. Connecticut's education department describes School Day results as comparable to scores from other SAT administrations. In Colorado, where juniors take the SAT as the state test, 25,122 of the 59,203 SAT takers in the class of 2025 chose to send score reports to colleges or other institutions.
What are the SAT college readiness benchmarks?
College Board sets them at 480 for Reading and Writing and 530 for Math. A student who meets a section benchmark has a 75% chance of earning at least a C in a related first-semester college course. The PSAT reports earlier grade-level benchmarks, such as 460 and 510 for eleventh graders.
My child scored "advanced" on the state math test. Will they do well on SAT Math?
They will very likely clear the SAT Math benchmark of 530. The top label on a state test covers a wide range, though, so the label alone cannot tell you whether your child is closer to a 650 or an 800. In an SAT state, the section score on the same report will; elsewhere, a practice SAT will.
My child scored below proficient on the state test. Does that mean a low SAT score?
It suggests they would score below the SAT benchmark in that subject if they tested now. In Connecticut's grade 8 data, at most about a third of students below the state standard in math met the PSAT 8/9 math benchmark that fall. A state score in middle school or early high school leaves time to close the gap before the SAT.
Can I use NAEP results to judge my child's SAT readiness?
No. NAEP, the "Nation's Report Card," reports results for states and groups of students and does not produce individual scores. Federal research links NAEP to the SAT to estimate how prepared students are as a group, not how any one student will score.
Sources
- College Board: 2025 West Virginia SAT Suite of Assessments Annual Report (2025)
- College Board: 2025 Total Group SAT Suite of Assessments Annual Report (2025)
- College Board: 2025 Colorado SAT Suite of Assessments Annual Report (2025)
- College Board: SAT Suite Benchmarks
- Colorado Department of Education: Assessment Fact Sheets and FAQs
- Connecticut State Department of Education: Connecticut SAT School Day
- Connecticut State Department of Education: Report Notes: Connecticut School Day SAT
- Connecticut State Department of Education: SAT Multi-State Standard Setting Report (2016)
- Connecticut State Department of Education: The Relationship between the Smarter Balanced 8th Grade Assessments and the PSAT 8/9 Assessments
- Delaware Department of Education: 2025-26 DeSSA Calendar (2025)
- Indiana Department of Education: High School Assessments
- Michigan Department of Education: Michigan Merit Examination and PSAT
- Michigan Department of Education: Interpretive Guide to MME Reports (2026)
- New Hampshire Department of Education: Office of Assessment
- New Mexico Public Education Department: 2025-26 Assessment and Accountability Program Requirements (April 8, 2025)
- Rhode Island Department of Education: SAT
- West Virginia Department of Education: SAT School Day
- Illinois State Board of Education: High School Assessment (ACT + Science + Writing, PreACT Secure, PreACT 9 Secure)
- Kurlaender and Cohen, Policy Analysis for California Education: Predicting College Success: How Do Different High School Assessments Measure Up? (March 2019)
- Moran, Oranje, and Freund, National Assessment Governing Board: NAEP 12th Grade Preparedness Research: SAT-NAEP Linking Study
- National Center for Education Statistics: Mapping State Proficiency Standards Onto the NAEP Scales: Results From the 2022 NAEP Reading and Mathematics Assessments (February 2026)
- Nichols-Barrer, Place, Dillon, and Gill (Mathematica Policy Research), Education Next: "Testing College Readiness: Massachusetts compares the validity of two standardized tests" (Summer 2016)



